Progress Report provides ongoing impressions of games as I play them.
Hillbrad Foothills begins on a comedic note, giving players a nice reprieve from the high dramatics that closed out Silverpine Forest. And yet, no matter how silly the initial quest is, which places you in the position of being a quest-giver to three exaggerated "player" archetypes, what might have been a disposable quest recurs in future quests, including a surprising quest chain that ends up poignant. That's right, WoW somehow takes a comedic beat from what could be a throwaway quest and develops it into a rather poignant story.
Otherwise, questing in Hillsbrad Foothills is rather straightforward, with you typical kill/fetch quests leading up to mini-events. There are about three of these moments overall and the middle one is the aforementioned poignant one--I really love how Blizzard created an actual character to connect with, no matter how briefly. In terms of the overall look of the zone, the Forsaken have clearly made their inroads, blowing up Southshore, which has become a slimy cesspool and Hillsbrad. In Hillsbrad, you are actually given an interesting moral choice, which doesn't really affect the game and I found that interesting as well.
Unfortunately, the zone doesn't end with an epic sweeping story like Silverpine Forest, instead it ends a touch on a goofy side, which still includes a dose of personality, but doesn't really draw you into any greater story. Furthermore, the Alterac Mountains get incorporated into Hillsbrad Foothills, but there is no quest chain that goes up there, despite having NPCs placed up there--it seems like those plans were abandoned. This leaves a giant mini-zone completely without purpose and seems like a bit of a loss for the character of the zone, because it is one of the few Horde friendly snow-covered areas in the game.
Also in line with the goofy nature of the zone is the inclusion of a Plants vs. Zombies game, affectionately nicknamed "Lawn of the Dead" included in the zone, which rewards an item appropriate for players questing in the area, but scaling monetary and experience rewards for all players. Unfortunately, there is no breadcrumb quest to send anyone out there, so it feels a little disconnected from the zone, despite the fact that, based on its item rewards and characters, it should have been led to fairly early in the zone.
I suppose a nice change of pace like Hillsbrad Foothills goofiness is a plus after the epic Silverpine Forest and it does contain at least some strong flavor thanks to the continuing story that opens up the zone, but after Silverpine, it can feel like a touch of a letdown, especially when you consider the now meaningless Alterac Mountains. The other difficult factor is that there is a bunch of group quests in the area, most of which cannot be beaten solo, even when they are deemed beneath a character and since the area, like most lower level areas, is barren, getting a group together to beat the bosses can be quite difficult. More so than actually beating the bosses should you find a group. Still, in the end, I enjoyed the zone's variety and the goofiness did enliven the area enough to keep it fun. When all is said and done, a very basic breadcrumb quest leading players to the Arathi Highlands, which was a rather boring zone before the Shattering of the original World of Warcraft.
Links:
- Game website
Zone Index: